Looking to protect your home systems and appliances?
No system or appliance is too old for AHS home warranty coverage and all of our plans include our 30-day workmanship guarantee.
Find coverage in your area
What to Ask When Choosing a Home Warranty
When choosing a home warranty, the most important questions fall into two categories: what to ask yourself, and what to ask the company. Start by assessing your home's coverage needs and budget, then dig into the plan agreement details: coverage limits, exclusions, the service request process, and how repair Pros are selected. Knowing what to ask before you sign makes it easier to find a plan that actually holds up when something breaks. Learn more about AHS home warranty coverage and how a plan can help protect the systems and appliances you rely on most.
In this article:
How to compare home warranty companies
Questions to ask the home warranty company
Key takeaways
- Not all home warranty plans cover the same things. Knowing what questions to ask helps you avoid coverage gaps.
- Before shopping, assess your home's age, your appliance conditions, and your budget for both monthly costs and service fees.
- Red flags could include vague contract language, hidden exclusions, and low coverage caps that may leave you paying out of pocket.
- American Home Shield covers normal wear and tear regardless of the age of the covered item, unknown, pre-existing conditions, and items without maintenance records.
How to compare home warranty companies
What differentiates home warranty companies?
Home warranty companies may look similar on the surface, but the differences show up in the details: what's covered, what's excluded, and how to use your plan. Coverage limits, service fees, contractor networks, and plan terms all vary considerably from one company to the next.
The best way to compare is to go beyond the marketing and read the actual plan agreement. What counts as a covered breakdown? What exclusions apply? Are there dollar caps on repairs for specific systems? These are the questions that help determine whether a plan delivers when you need it.
What red flags should I watch out for?
| What to Look For | What You Could Find with Some Home Warranties | What You Get with AHS |
| Coverage exclusions | Vague language around "improper maintenance," leaving claims vulnerable to denial on a technicality | Clear contract terms, plus coverage for items with unknown maintenance history and undetectable pre-existing conditions |
| Systems coverage limits | Low per-item caps that are sometimes just a few hundred dollars, falling short of real repair costs | Up to $5,000 coverage for HVAC, electrical, and plumbing systems |
| Appliance coverage limits | Minimal caps that may not cover replacement for major appliances | Up to $2,000–$4,000 in appliance coverage depending on your plan |
| Claims process | Unclear or hard-to-reach service request process | Request service 24/7 online, via the AHS app, or by phone |
| Service fee flexibility | One-size-fits-all pricing with no ability to adjust your service fee | Choose a service fee option that fits your budget |
| Item age & history | Coverage often limited to newer items or those with documented maintenance records | Coverage for breakdowns regardless of the age of the covered item, no maintenance records required |
See the plan agreement for coverage details, including service fees, limitations and exclusions. Coverage limits and charges for non-covered items may apply.
Questions to ask when choosing a home warranty
Before comparing plans, it helps to know what you're looking for. These questions will help you clarify your needs and set your priorities.
What coverage do I need?
Start with an honest look at your home. Which systems and appliances are most important to you, and most likely to need repair? An older home with aging HVAC equipment has different coverage needs than a newer build with recent appliances under manufacturer warranty.
Think about which items would be most expensive or disruptive to repair without a plan: heating and cooling systems, water heaters, electrical panels, kitchen appliances. Then look for plans that cover those items specifically rather than settling for generic "all-appliance" language that may have more exclusions than coverage.
What is my budget for monthly costs and service fees?
Home warranty plans usually involve two costs: the monthly (or annual) cost and the service fee you pay when a contractor comes out. These two numbers are often inversely related—lower monthly costs tend to come with higher service fees, and vice versa. Understanding your tolerance for each helps you pick a plan structure that fits your financial situation.
Also think about what you're already spending on repairs. If your systems or appliances have needed fixing more than once in the last few years, a plan with broader coverage might be worth the extra few dollars a month. One thing worth knowing: your plan may help cover problems you didn't know about, even ones that were already brewing before your plan started. It just won't cover something you already knew was broken. Compare AHS plan costs to see how different coverage tiers and service fees stack up.
How important are additional services and perks?
Some home warranty companies offer extras beyond basic repair and replacement coverage: appliance discounts, smart home device coverage, roof leak protection, or tech tools that make it easier to request service. If those things matter to you, look for them in the plan details rather than assuming they're included.
How much wear and tear do your appliances already have?
The age and condition of your appliances affects what kind of coverage is realistic to expect. Many home warranty companies exclude coverage for pre-existing conditions or require items to be in good working order at the start of your plan. If you have appliances that are already showing signs of wear, that's worth understanding before you enroll.
American Home Shield covers normal wear and tear regardless of a covered item's age, along with unknown pre-existing breakdowns and items without maintenance records.
What should I look for when comparing plans?
Customer reviews
What existing customers say about a company when things go wrong tells you a lot. Look for reviews that speak to the claims or service request experience, not just the enrollment process. Did the company respond promptly? Were disputes handled fairly? Were there surprise denials? AHS has a strong track record backed by member testimonials.
Compare coverage and coverage limits
Side-by-side plan comparisons can be tricky because companies don't always use the same language for similar items. Focus on the systems and appliances that matter most to your home, and compare coverage caps for each. A plan that covers everything at a low dollar limit may be less valuable than a more targeted plan with higher per-item limits.
Review costs
Total cost isn't just the monthly cost. Factor in the service fee per visit, any enrollment fees, and whether there are additional costs for add-on coverage. Consider the value relative to what you'd likely spend on repairs out of pocket and look for available discounts that might make a plan more affordable.
Know what to ask
Download our What to Ask When Choosing a Home Warranty PDF today.
Why homeowners choose American Home Shield
When comparing home warranty options, the details matter. Here's what sets AHS apart.
Shield Assurances
Rest easy. With our Shield Assurances, we take care of things other home warranty companies might not, like:
- Normal wear and tear, no matter the age of a covered item
- Unknown, pre-existing breakdowns
- Items without maintenance records
- Duplicates of the same item, like that extra AC unit
- Removal of defective equipment
- Refrigerant recapture, reclaim, and disposal
- Breakdowns caused by improper installations or repairs, insufficient maintenance; rust, corrosion, and sediment; and mismatched HVAC systems
See the plan agreement for coverage details, including service fees, limitations and exclusions. Coverage limits and charges for non-covered items may apply.
Broad, flexible coverage
AHS plans are built to be customized. Choose from multiple plan tiers covering home systems, appliances, or both—and add coverage for specific items your home needs—like roof leak coverage, pool and built in spa coverage or our third party electronics protection coverage. Whether you need broader coverage or targeted options for specific systems, there's a plan that fits.
Longstanding leader
American Home Shield invented the home warranty industry more than 50 years ago. That kind of experience means a depth of coverage, contractor relationships, and Service request claim expertise that newer companies are still building. Learn more about AHS.
Tech tools
Managing your home warranty should be easy. The AHS app lets you request service, pay your Service Fee, track your Pro assignment, and manage your account from anywhere. As a benefit, members with select plans can also connect with a live repair Expert via video chat for faster diagnosis before an in-person Pro visit.
Nationwide network of Pros
When you request service, AHS dispatches from a national network of qualified, independent repair Pros—trusted contractors ready to handle the repairs your home needs. No hunting for Pros on your own.
When you know the right questions, choosing a home warranty gets a lot simpler. Explore AHS coverage options and find a plan built for your home.
AHS assumes no responsibility, and specifically disclaims all liability, for your use of any and all information contained herein.
Frequently Asked Questions
For most homeowners, yes—especially if your appliances and systems are aging or you'd rather have budget protection than unpredictable out-of-pocket expenses. A home warranty can save you from a surprise HVAC repair or a dishwasher replacement you didn't budget for. Whether it makes sense for your specific situation depends on your home's age, your risk tolerance, and your existing coverage.
A home warranty typically covers the repair of parts of major home systems and appliances that break down due to normal wear and tear. In the case of AHS home warranties, if they can't repair it, they'll replace it. This includes items like heating and cooling systems, plumbing, electrical, water heaters, and kitchen appliances. Coverage varies by plan. See what AHS covers for a detailed breakdown.
Yes. AHS covers normal wear and tear on covered items regardless of age. Older appliances aren't excluded just because they've been in service for a while—if a covered component breaks down from regular use, you can request service.
No. AHS does not require maintenance records as a condition of coverage. This is one of the key differences between AHS and some other providers, and part of what makes our Shield Assurances meaningful for homeowners who may not have documentation on every appliance.
